Overcast
Actually, it is quite sunny today. But I was referring to the mood in the East Jerusalem office this morning. I'd seen the headlines, but I clearly wasn't aware of how very damaging everything was looking until I walked in: My normally lively office was a funeral parlour- I almost asked if someone had died, I'd never seen so many glum faces. Hamas sweeping the Palestinian elections was definitely not the outcome any of them had been hoping for.
Now my colleagues are all expressing grave concern about the veritable uncertainty which now hangs over Palestinian Society and themselves as individual Citizens, Women, Social Activists, Christians, or non-practising Muslims. Further, crucial foreign aid to thousands of Palestinian welfare projects could be seriously jeopardised: waves of panic are now raging afresh throughout the NGO sector.
And what hopes are there of any Israeli - or even US- negotiations with such a Government? With everybody refusing to talk to everybody else, the future looks far from bright...
"Don't forget your Hijab on Monday!" one of my colleagues shouted at me as she left, with a wry smile.
And so begins the black humour. I think we're going to need a lot more where that came from.
Now my colleagues are all expressing grave concern about the veritable uncertainty which now hangs over Palestinian Society and themselves as individual Citizens, Women, Social Activists, Christians, or non-practising Muslims. Further, crucial foreign aid to thousands of Palestinian welfare projects could be seriously jeopardised: waves of panic are now raging afresh throughout the NGO sector.
And what hopes are there of any Israeli - or even US- negotiations with such a Government? With everybody refusing to talk to everybody else, the future looks far from bright...
"Don't forget your Hijab on Monday!" one of my colleagues shouted at me as she left, with a wry smile.
And so begins the black humour. I think we're going to need a lot more where that came from.
22 Comments:
At 5:26 PM,
Jameel @ The Muqata said…
Parrot: Who do you think is better for the Palestinian population?
Hamas: Albeit radical fundamentalists, they eschew corruption, extortion, theft, rape and many of the other unsavory qualities of the Fatah and PA police units.
PA/Fatah: A gang of thugs, terrorists and criminals from Tunis -- many of whom have zero issues with terrorizing their own population for fun and profit. Can be "moderate" as a means of furthering their own corruption (and tacit policy of destroying Israel)
I'm not sure that the Hamas is really "worse" for Israel...or the Palestinians themselves.
I'll probably get it over the head for writing this...and from a radical settler too.
Oh well. Worse things have happened.
At 7:01 PM,
lisoosh said…
Jameel - I'm surprised, and impressed. A well thought out comment.
At 7:28 PM,
Anonymous said…
Jameel, the "albeit radical fundamentalists" line is the part you need to be concentrating on here. Palestinians are not by and large radical fundamentalists.
At 4:07 AM,
Anonymous said…
I can't shake the feeling that the vote for Hamas was an expression of the idea that all politics are domestic.. that the Palestinians were voting against the crap fatah leadership, rather than voting for hamas...
having said that, the lack of another option other than hamas says something too..
you'll have to forgive me that after shooting themselves in the foot again, people around the world stop giving money to the palestinians on the off-chance it may go to a terrorist organistion whose stated aim is the destruction of israel...
for this particular little fuck up, you have to point the finger at the palestinian voter.
zsta
At 9:11 AM,
tafka PP said…
I'm not blaming anyone, or saying that I think Fatah is better. (I never thought Arafat was much of a "Partner" either.)
I was merely moved to share what I saw yesterday- a bunch of depressed and scared Palestinians who don't understand how this happened (they don't know any Hamas voters themselves) and definitely don't feel represented by Hamas, whether or not they actively supported Fatah.
I guess time will tell...
At 4:06 PM,
westbankmama said…
They were seriously surprised at the outcome? They didn't realize how corruption at the top has soured the voters at the bottom?
I also find it not a little disgusting that the aspect of Islamic fundamentalism that bothers them the most is the threat of a dress code - rather than the encouragement of suicide bombings.
What are they more afraid of - wearing a hijab or the prospect of one of their children being brainwashed into blowing himself up? And what does that say about their culture?
At 5:15 PM,
Anonymous said…
Don't know how this happened????
Didn't think Hamas could have gotten a decent chunk of the votes??? are they blind??
There is a point up to which people have to take responsibilty for the society they live in... a leftie can't just say... "Oh, I didn't think that the right wing party would get any votes" if there has been a total lack of protest at the gathering of strength in the right wing camp.
The 'moderate' palestinians have failed to provide any alternative to fatah or hamas and thus, can't pretend to be shocked when the corrupt fatah gets thrown out...
not impressed , or sympathetic, to your colleagues parrot.. sorry.
zsta
At 8:44 PM,
lisoosh said…
Parrot - just wanted to say I was impressed by some of your comments on other boards and the fact that you look at this from both sides.
I'd guess a lot of Palestinians are surprised due to the fact that Fatah was leading in the polls. Do you have any idea how many people may have made a "protest" vote based on the assumption that Hamas wouldn't win? And more importantly, are there any indications that you can see that once the shock wears off there may be a possibility of civil war?
At 9:25 PM,
tafka PP said…
WestBankMama- thanks for commenting, but I don't understand why you are so quick to judge their entire society based on the one sarcastic comment I chose to repeat in this post. I do not claim to have answers about Palestinian social priorities, I was just reporting how my colleagues- by and large, a group of feminists- were devastated by the Hamas win. I think it is fair to say that they, as social change activists, are very in tune with what is wrong in their society, although they might not agree with your personal diagnosis or judgements of their culture.
Ditto ZSTA: Why assume that my colleagues aren't troubled by corruption? And- again- I wasn't saying that they were upset because Fatah lost- but because Hamas won. And finally, I wasn't asking for your sympathy on their behalf, I was simply trying to bring another perspective which you won't be exposed to via any media outlets anytime soon. Political commentary is all very well, I thought people might be interested in the "street" (while I'm still on that street!)
Lisoosh- thanks...I will look into the "protest votes" qu- I heard some hypothesising on that point but not much more. And as for Civil War- G-d, I hope not... but bear in mind I work in the Civil Society sector so I'll be the last person to hear!
At 9:33 PM,
Anonymous said…
It would be so much easier to make peace with the Palestinians if it wasn't for the Palestinians.
(Insert Abba Eban's quote here).
At least all the cards are on the table now, no faffing.
Yellow Boy
At 12:49 PM,
Jameel @ The Muqata said…
Jameel - I'm surprised, and impressed. A well thought out comment.
Lisoosh: I'm not quite sure if that was a compliment or not...I'll have to think about that.
DH: Whether Palestinians are largely radical fundamentalists or not is irrelavent, considering that they voted overwhelmingly for a radical fundamentalist regime.
Personally, I find it laughable that Israel has officially announced that they won't negotiate with a Hamas-run PA. Dollars to Donuts, I PROMISE you that Israel will be talking to them at some point in time (if they aren't already, under the table).
How's this for a curve ball: Maybe the reason Israel claims they don't want to talk to the Hamas is purely based on their distaste of organized religion?
At the end of the day, are the Hamas really worse for us because they are religious? Why do people think the Fatah is any better?
Could religion be the trump card issue which brands the Hamas as unacceptable?
At 1:49 PM,
MC Aryeh said…
TAFKAP - You offer an important voice on the blogosphere. I don't personally know anyone who has daily contact with Palestinians. I think that offers you a view into their society most of the rest of us do not have.
That said, regardless of why Hamas was voted into power, I don't think they will be good for Israel or for the Palestinians. At least Israel knows who they are dealing with. Do the Palestinians?
I ask that not in a snarky way. I am genuinely curious as to what the average Palestinian thinks voting Hamas into power will bring them - better standard of living? an end to curruption? the destruction of Israel? a fundamentalist society? How can they not think it is all four?
At 2:55 PM,
Jameel @ The Muqata said…
MCAryeh: Snarky?! What a fabulous word! I must use that in my next sonnet! :)
I just want to go on record and say I don't believe that TAFKAP has a way of really finding out what the "average" Palestinian has to say. Till she finds one who openly admits to her to voting Hamas, she's not talking to an "average" Palestinian.
At 3:02 PM,
MC Aryeh said…
Snarky pales in comparison to glop, both in sonnets and real life...
At 3:09 PM,
tafka PP said…
McA- I don't know about how the average Palestinian thinks, I only know that my colleagues did not vote for the reasons you cited. They did mention that the Hamas anti-corruption campaign was likely the biggest "swinger." Check out the Mother-From-Gaza blog in my sidebar (and her links too) if you want some more genuine Palestinian feedback.
Jameel- I would respectfully ask you not to make such generalisations.
At 3:55 PM,
Jameel @ The Muqata said…
TAFKATP: As respectful as possible, I would like to pose the following query to you:
Fact: The Hamas have received a majority vote.
Fact: You claim that your colleagues are scared of Hamas being the ruling party.
Therefore - If you know average Palestinians, they must have voted for Hamas, right? Yet, you said they are all upset and scared...
I'm totally for respect...but how did my "generalization" miss its mark?
Respectfully yours,
Jameel.
At 4:02 PM,
tafka PP said…
Jameel- I never claimed to know "Average" Palestinians any more than I would claim to be an "Average" Israeli/Brit.
I think generalizations and talks of "Average" are silly. That is what I was respectfully asking you to refrain from.
At 5:36 PM,
lisoosh said…
Jameel it was a compliment. I'd just finished reading a lot of knee-jerk reaction.
At 5:32 PM,
Anonymous said…
jameel's point about average people seems to be right... your co-workers views are important, like you said, to hear what are the varying points of view from the street (ouch!) but how representative are their views?
could you ask them what they think and then post about it?
zsta
At 5:47 PM,
tafka PP said…
*Swigs Rescue Remedy* I never claimed to be representative. However, that doesn't invalidate the response of my co-workers.
I would venture that a large amount of people who work in the non-profit sector feel similarly to my colleagues.
As I said to McAryeh, look at "A Mother From Gaza" and her links if you want a more representative response from the "street": I personally don't really fancy my chances walking around E Jerusalem asking random Palestinians if they are happy about the Hamas win!
At 9:09 AM,
Anonymous said…
just to add my intellectual contribution to this discussion. i just voted for you! yeah!! all is good on this happy sunny day! love s
At 12:02 AM,
Anonymous said…
enough with the intellectual posturing - let's get to the real issue at hand, that's been skirted around long enough. everyone, no matter what your persuasion, needs the answer to this and then everything else will fall into place:
what the hell was the parrot doing waking up in an old age home and why won't she tell all?
Post a Comment
<< Home