Slightly Mad

Yeah, I stopped blogging in 2008. Bye now.

Saturday, April 29, 2006

Cerebral Implosion

Disclaimer: I'd likely not be able to type if my cranium had actually imploded. Fun imagery, though, no?

I'm feeling a little more overcooked than usual at present, what with the Post-Passover Psychosis setting in and this highly charged time of year in these parts. Last week was Holocaust Rememberance Day, and coming up we've got Memorial Day (I wrote about it last year) followed immediately by Independence Day, ergo barbeques and booze celebrating the birth of the State. And so my circuits, sensitive at the best of times, are just about primed to shut down: Not for nothing is this blog called "Slightly Mad" - this is traditionally the season wherein I find it most difficult to flit between the two "sides" of Jerusalem, and this year it feels more of a challenge than ever. What with both Israeli and Palestinian societies so very politically overloaded at present, every terror attack, IDF incursion, individual expression of nationalism and of course all accompanying reportage, appears to be more weighted than in previous years. Or maybe it's just me. But I don't think so. There's too much to deal with, and I don't seem to have enough brainspace.

More than once, Israeli and immigrant friends have remarked to me, "Well, no wonder you get frustrated and depressed about the state of things- you should do something else for a living, you'd be happier." While I doubt there is much truth in this contention, I do wonder as to how much of our society functions in total denial as to the way the land lies: I read other local blogs and often find myself despairing that there are so many who inhabit this area seemingly in a state of selective vision or even blinkered self-centeredness, and can't quite believe that we live in the same region. (I'm not going to highlight specific blogs here, but my blogroll has some good examples) Important issues regarding the harsh realities of Jews and Arabs sharing this land- ones that I am forced to confront on a daily basis- appear to not be an ingredient of most peoples' existence. And when we are made to take stock by dint of these days of mourning and celebration, for me it is increasingly impossible to ignore the bigger picture. Which isn't pretty, frankly: Some days it is enough to make me want to get on a plane and start a new life on the Cook Islands. But I'm not going to. There's still plenty about my life here that I value and enjoy: It is just hard to keep track of that in this week of grandstanding. Just as well then, that getting wasted has been incorporated within the modern celebratory traditions!

A Palestinian friend suggested that maybe we should set up a support group, for all those on either side who try to remain moderate and objective and keep hold of their sanity simultaneously. Now I think about it, it isn't a bad idea at all- we could probably even get some EU Funding! Well, that will be something to contemplate while nursing the hangover on the morning of Israel's 58th Birthday.

19 Comments:

  • At 9:18 AM, Blogger miketheman said…

    I agree that a lot of blogs do not cover the greater picture, but that's only becuase as individuals, we may accept the "facts of life" here and not discuss them as vehemently as the latest fashionss, etc because these are things we can actually deal with.
    I drive through two inspection points every morning on my way to work. They have bumps before and after the spots that cause havoc with my bike. These inspections are pretty useless, in my opinion, but they are part of my reality of living in Israel.
    Why moan and groan? It's not going to change anytime soon.

     
  • At 1:03 PM, Blogger Jameel @ The Muqata said…

    Err, does that mean there won't be seperate seating at the "support group, for all those on either side who try to remain moderate and objective and keep hold of their sanity simultaneously"?

    I don't know if everyone "moderate" is ready to go to such a meeting...

     
  • At 5:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Oy yoy yoy
    http://jewschool.com/?p=10488
    YB

     
  • At 6:28 PM, Blogger tafka PP said…

    GGreen- thank you thank you. Emailing you this evening- hope we haven't seen the last of you...

    MTM- Yo! You are right, and I'll talk about everything too (as you know) *But* it does suck that it isn't "going to change anytime soon" when I'm trying to bring about the opposite.

    Jameel- I don't know if they are either. Maybe if the EU was sponsoring the refreshments more people would be enticed!

    YB- I share in your sorrow. But hey at least her name and accompanying genius is immortalised forever...we should all be so lucky...

     
  • At 8:47 PM, Blogger westbankmama said…

    Very interesting post. I wonder sometimes if people don't want to be "moderate and objective" because it means feeling the pain of both sides of the conflict - and in this part of the world that is just too much pain to absorb.

     
  • At 10:56 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    Kudos, YB!

     
  • At 10:07 AM, Blogger Ze'ev said…

    As one of the blogs that seemingly suffers from "selective vision or even blinkered self-centeredness", I figured I would offer my two cents.

    It's as if, b/c I believe in that the right of the Jewish People to the Land of Israel, both based on the Torah, but based on history and international law, is dominant to that of any other claim, that I am willfully ignoring reality. Why must reality mean being willing to give away our Homeland, or to capitulate in the face of terrorists?

    I recognize that there are Arabs (be they Palestinians or otherwise) that are suffering, yet, I do not believe that the ultimate responsibility for their suffering rests at my feet. I recognize that there are many Israeli Arabs who feel that they do not have equal rights - and many of them likely are not terrorists - but again, if they want full equality, and want to be able to shape the future of a country and express their nationalism, there are plenty of others places for them to do so.

    I am not blind, and I am not naive. I recognize all of these things and more, but above all, I recognize that this Land belongs to the Jewish People, and that the Muslim world is not prepared to accept that, and at the end of the day, only one of us will win out. I do not apologize for my beliefs, and I do not apologize for living in the Jewish State of Israel.

    It is unfortunate that since the inception of the State and since the end of the 6 Day War, our leaders have given ambivalent and misleading statements as to who we are and why we are, which only causes pain and suffering to both Jews and non-Jews.

    I hope for peace, just as you, I just do not believe it will come in the way that you do. Does that make me a bad person, or a blind person?

    I don't think so, but you are certainly entitled to disagree with me, and so lon as we are both living here, we share the same fate and future.

     
  • At 8:26 PM, Blogger kasamba said…

    I really wanted to say something, but I'm waiting for you to answer Zeev.

     
  • At 10:50 AM, Blogger tafka PP said…

    Ze'ev- first of all I really appreciate you commenting. And I definitely don't think that your opinions, or your decision to live over the green line, makes you a bad person!

    I don't recall defining "reality" as "being willing to give away our Homeland, or to capitulate in the face of terrorists." But as you've called me on it, I'll define reality as being aware that Jews aren't the only people living- and planning on staying- in Israel, like it or not. Therefore to my mind, grandstanding about the Jewish Homeland for the Jewish People as a single issue is not facing that reality. (I also disagree with your definition of "Jewish", but that was on your blog, not here) I'm not even going to touch on the "and many of them are likely not terrorists" comment, but I'll take great issue at your contention that "Israeli Arabs" are free to leave if they don't like it here. If that isn't "willfully ignoring reality", I don't know what does.

    Like you, I do not apologize for living in the Jewish State of Israel. It is a choice I made having been influenced by the same Zionist Youth Movement as (I think) you were in. I am not blind either, especially not to home-grown, hate/propaganda-filled, Palestinian terrorism. But all said, I recognize that mistakes have been made by an egotistical Israeli leadership in the past which have greatly harmed our standing today. You and I may disagree with which mistakes were made, and by whom, but the fact is that at this point, we are no longer in a position to imagine that the problems will just disappear if we continue as is. Yes, of course it is important that we remain faithful to our Jewishness- but relinquishing land is not, and should not be interpreted, as contradictory to that basic premise. It is not capitulating to terrorism, far from it- rather, very painful steps in view of the reality. And who knows what will happen in the future. I don't. Do you?

    For me, the reality is impossible to ignore, especially since I have gone to the other extreme as those I accuse of being "blinkered" and chosen to work within the "other" population. I'm not advocating that everyone should do that, or even that the "ultimate responsibility" rests at your- or my- feet. But acknowledging their continued presence here (beyond lip service) and figuring out ways to live together while ensuring our own safety and future to my mind has to be a priority for everyone.

     
  • At 10:52 AM, Blogger tafka PP said…

    West Bank Mama- Absolutely, that was exactly the point I was trying to make!

    Kasamba- I've replied to Ze'ev, I'm looking forward to hearing from you...

     
  • At 12:50 PM, Blogger Dot Co Dot Il said…

    Nice blog parrot. You like Australian Cadburys as well?

     
  • At 1:00 PM, Blogger JJ said…

    I keep coming back to this post, trying to come up with a somewhat cohesive, intelligent comment to the serious issues you bring up...but the words just ain't coming.

    So...I'll just say that the imagery of your cranium imploding really is something- all those feathers everywhere!

     
  • At 5:12 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said…

    You were in the same Zionist youth movement with the settler guy??

    This is very new information for me!

     
  • At 1:09 AM, Blogger kasamba said…

    Hello TafkaPP darlin!
    Well, about arab/jew relationships; I have cousin in Israel who joins palestenian and israeli musicians for concerts all over the world. I went to one in the Royal Festival Hall here in London and they showcased a palestinian woman singing in front of an israeli orchestra.

    I think I would have enjoyed it more had the palestinian woman not sounded like she was being hung, drawn and quartered, while a thousand bees were stinging her.
    (come visit my meme!)

     
  • At 10:36 AM, Blogger tafka PP said…

    Dot co dot il- nice to meet you yesterday- and as I told you, after a bag of Strawberry Freddos, I'm anyone's...

    RR- glad that the imagery had the desired effect!

    DH- have we never had that conversation?!

    Kasamba- Ooh, I know exactly which orchestra you are referring to, and I too have had that pleasure ;-)

     
  • At 2:26 PM, Blogger Ze'ev said…

    PP, it might surprise you, but I never grew up in any Zionist youth movement. I was a late bloomer, only stared getting itnerested in Israel during my year in Israel at the age of 17.

    Also, if one truly believes in the right of the Jewish People to this Land, both from a Biblical, as well as legal perspective, why is it wrong for them to stand for their pricinples and their faith?

    There is very little in Jewish history that has ever gone in accordance with "reality", b/c if it did, neither we, not the Jewish State would exist any longer. I can't believe that a jew statying true to the teaching of his fathers (and of Sinai) is doing something wrong.

    I am sure there is a workable soloution that can be found without us having to give up what rightfully belongs to us. Sadly, it has been proven time and again that the Muslim / Arab world is not interested in any type of compromise, as they have rejected so many offers for P-Statehood - they just wont accept the permanent presence of a Jewish State in the Land of Israel - and that's unfortunate - but that doesnt change about how the Jewish people should relatetowards their Heritage and Inhertiance.

     
  • At 3:04 PM, Blogger tafka PP said…

    Ze'ev-

    Who said it was wrong for you or any Jew to stand for principles of faith and "the teachings of his fathers"? I don't have a problem with principles of faith at all. I have a problem in this context with singular *interpretation* of those principles and teachings vis a vis the Arab residents of this land, and the convenient use of "they will never accept us" as an excuse.

     
  • At 3:59 PM, Blogger Ze'ev said…

    PP, I accept that you have a problem when someone tried to speak in the name of Judaism, but, what if what the person is saying happens to be correct?

    For instance, if a person believes in the divitnity of the Law (both Written and oral) then they will accept the fact that someone who decides to "observe the Sabbath", by partying at a disco and then driving to the beach is not "observing the Sabbath" as it was intended to be observed.

    That being said, again, assuming that one believes in the divinity of the Written and Oral Law, then there isn't that much of a question relating ot the status on Non-Jews in Israel, nor towards the right fo the Jewish People to the Land.

    It becomes a question of exactly what can and can't we be doing today to fulfill our responsibilities / obligations - but over the foundation of whose Land this is (and isn't) there is no doubt.

    Of course, if soneone does not beleive in the divinity of the Written and Oral Law, then it would be like comparing apples and oranges. You might be both be talking about fruit, but thats where the common language ends.

    As for the fact that they won't accept us, there are so many examples.

    Just to list a few:

    1) The Arabs / Muslims in 1922, even after 75% of the land included in the British Mandate to be set aside for the creation of a Jewish State was illegally used by the British to create the fictious Hashemite Kingdom of Jordan, the Arabs were still unwilling ot accept a Jewish State on 25% of the Land.

    2) In 1937 the Arabs rejected the Peel comission that would have granted them a state West of the Jordan on half of the Land...

    3) In 1947 the Arabs rejected the partition Plan that would also have alloed for the establishment of a P-State west of the Jordan.

    4) Between the years of 1948 - 1967, there was no talk of establishing a P-State in the areas illegally occupied by Egypt and Jordan (Gaza, and Judea and Samaria). It was only after their war of extermination in 1967 failed, that hey began talking about occupied territories.

    5) Arafat rejected barak's Camp David offerthat would have given them a P-State on 95%+ of Judea, Samaria and Aza.

     
  • At 4:37 PM, Blogger tafka PP said…

    Ok- I think we're way beyond fruit at this stage if we're still fighting over basic truths, Ze'ev!

    I return to my original point: It would seem that, as I suspected, we really are living in different countries, with different perceptions of "reality" - and I can only wonder what it will take for that to change. The Iranian threat, maybe?! - along the lines of the film "Independence Day"? Ooh, if I'd written that yesterday, that could have been a funky pun.

    I really do appreciate you commenting. I probably will avoid politics in the meantime, but come back soon.

     

Post a Comment

<< Home

Powered by Blogger